Hunter KillerCreate free account
Menu

Public performance record

See what held up after prediction.

The Money Map publishes liquidation levels first. Later, the actual tape tells us which levels were reached. Every performance claim includes the result, the sample size and a cautious lower bound. Misses stay public. Weak markets are benched.

Measured · walk-forward Published levels, scored by distance (BTC, ETH, SOL, XRP)

Levels 1 to 2% from price: 67.7% hit within 24 hours (n 1,920, 620 misses listed). 95% lower bound 65.5%.

Levels 2 to 5% from price: 54.3% hit within 72 hours (n 729, 333 misses listed). 95% lower bound 50.6%.

Levels 5 to 15% from price: 51.5% hit within 7 days (n 801, 388 misses listed). 95% lower bound 48.1%.

Every miss is listed.

Buckets below the display bar are not shown on sales pages until they clear it.

Each level is scored once, against true price bars after publication. 1,738 levels are still inside their window and are not counted. As of 2026-11-16. Publication is logged before the outcome exists, so the record is walk-forward by construction. Levels closer than the first bucket are not scored: a near-spot level is reached almost by default. This is a record of past outcomes. Source: /proof/stats (published_levels).

How we grade ourselves

The longer record behind that sentence: window-level precision@N on every tracked symbol, the pooled out-of-sample track and the per-coin table. Every figure carries its sample size and a confidence bound.

Measured · walk-forward Liquidation-magnet levels: majors (BTC, ETH, SOL, XRP)

In plain English: Our majors levels hit 72% of the time, walk-forward and out-of-sample, checked over 276,328 real windows. The cautious number (95% floor): 67.7%. That is 56.1 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (15.9%), cautious floor 45.1 points.

72.1% hit rate: predicted levels that were touched
67.7% the cautious number: 95% confidence lower bound
276,328 real windows checked
Observed hit rate72.1%
Cautious floor67.7%
No-model baseline15.9%

Scored out-of-sample on data the model had never seen, walk-forward (only the calibration live at prediction time counts). We publish the conservative lower bound, never the flattering mean. Full derivation: /proof/stats · per-symbol table below · how we measure.

Across the whole governed pool (every served symbol, walk-forward out-of-sample): 59.2% of predicted levels were touched, honest 95% lower bound 35.7%, measured over 16 independent days. Descriptive history, not a forecast.

Complete provisional record

Every scored published level, in chronological order.

Hits and misses remain together in this provisional row record. Released headline figures stay separate.

Loading the complete scored row record…

Why this record is different

Published first. Scored later. Weak markets get benched.

1. We predict, then we wait. The map publishes predicted liquidation levels. Later, the real tape tells us which levels were actually touched. Nothing is scored on data the model had already seen.
2. Walk-forward only. A prediction counts only against the calibration that was live when it was made, never a refitted after-the-fact model. That is what “out-of-sample” means here.
3. Every number carries its count and its worst case. Next to every rate you see how many windows or independent days it rests on, plus the “cautious number”: a 95% confidence lower bound, the level the true rate is very unlikely to be below. We publish the floor, never the flattering mean.
4. Honest zeros stay visible. Things without enough evidence say UNVALIDATED or accruing, with the counters public. Symbols whose grade slips are benched and shown as benched. We would rather show you a gap than a guess.

The frozen metric contract: /methodology · the full scored ledger: /proof · machine-readable: /proof/stats · cryptographic anchor chain: /proof/anchors. Everything on this page is descriptive history, not a forecast, and not financial advice.

Market by market

The strongest proof is specific.

Every coin we track remains in the governed record. 15 of 44 tracked symbols currently publish a rate. A rate appears only with its count and its cautious bound; symbols benched by the served floor (Wilson floor below 25.0%) show the state and the number that benched them. We do not hide failing symbols, and we do not serve you a map whose grade slipped. 32 auto-disabled symbol(s) sit below the publish floor and are grouped in the collapsed section under the table and are benched, never hidden, never blended into the graded rows. Descriptive history, not a forecast.

BTC Serving · floor watch
45.5% levels reached
Cautious floor
23.9%
Windows
348
ETH Serving
83.0% levels reached
Cautious floor
58.0%
Windows
348
SOL Serving
53.7% levels reached
Cautious floor
30.4%
Windows
344
XRP Serving
79.1% levels reached
Cautious floor
53.9%
Windows
346
Open the complete governed table 15 publishing · 44 tracked · failures retained
CoinStateHit rate Cautious number (95% floor)Windows Independent daysEdge vs no-model baseline
AAPL AAPL →
Measurement note
AAPL levels hit 35% of the time, checked over 119 windows across 13 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 15.8%. That is 21.5 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 1.6 points.
Serving · floor watch 35.8% 15.9% 119 13 +21.5pp (floor +1.7pp)
BNB BNB →
Measurement note
BNB levels hit 60% of the time, checked over 286 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 36.3%. That is 46.4 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 22.1 points.
Serving 60.7% 36.4% 286 15 +46.5pp (floor +22.1pp)
BTC BTC →
Measurement note
BTC levels hit 45% of the time, checked over 348 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 23.9%. That is 31.2 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 9.6 points.
Serving · floor watch 45.5% 23.9% 348 15 +31.2pp (floor +9.7pp)
COIN COIN →
Measurement note
COIN levels hit 54% of the time, checked over 80 windows across 12 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 28.8%. That is 40.2 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 14.6 points.
Serving 54.5% 28.8% 80 12 +40.2pp (floor +14.6pp)
DOGE DOGE →
Measurement note
DOGE levels hit 49% of the time, checked over 326 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 27.2%. That is 35.4 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 12.9 points.
Serving 49.7% 27.2% 326 15 +35.5pp (floor +13.0pp)
ETH ETH →
Measurement note
ETH levels hit 82% of the time, checked over 348 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 57.9%. That is 68.7 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 43.7 points.
Serving 83.0% 58.0% 348 15 +68.7pp (floor +43.7pp)
PAXG PAXG →
Measurement note
PAXG levels hit 78% of the time, checked over 164 windows across 14 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 52.6%. That is 64.5 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 38.4 points.
Serving 78.8% 52.7% 164 14 +64.6pp (floor +38.4pp)
SOL SOL →
Measurement note
SOL levels hit 53% of the time, checked over 344 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 30.3%. That is 39.4 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 16.1 points.
Serving 53.7% 30.4% 344 15 +39.4pp (floor +16.2pp)
WLD WLD →
Measurement note
WLD levels hit 65% of the time, checked over 336 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 40.5%. That is 51.1 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 26.3 points.
Serving 65.4% 40.6% 336 15 +51.2pp (floor +26.3pp)
XAUT XAUT →
Measurement note
XAUT levels hit 68% of the time, checked over 209 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 43.4%. That is 54.3 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 29.2 points.
Serving 68.6% 43.5% 209 15 +54.3pp (floor +29.2pp)
XAU XAU →
Measurement note
XAU levels hit 55% of the time, checked over 325 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 31.7%. That is 41.0 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 17.4 points.
Serving 55.3% 31.7% 325 15 +41.0pp (floor +17.5pp)
XRP XRP →
Measurement note
XRP levels hit 79% of the time, checked over 346 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 53.9%. That is 64.8 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 39.6 points.
Serving 79.1% 53.9% 346 15 +64.9pp (floor +39.7pp)
Auto-disabled (below publish floor): 32 symbol(s). These coins fell under our auto-disable bar and are benched from serving; their rows keep the exact measured state and counters, grouped here so they never blend into the graded table.
CoinStateHit rate Cautious number (95% floor)Windows Independent daysEdge vs no-model baseline
1000PEPE 1000PEPE →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 14.7% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 347 15 —
AAVE AAVE →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 30.5% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 307 15 —
ADA ADA →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 21.3% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 300 15 —
APT APT →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 15.1% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 261 15 —
ARB ARB →
Measurement note
ARB levels hit 37% of the time, checked over 325 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 18.0%. That is 23.3 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor 3.8 points.
Serving · floor watch 37.6% 18.1% 325 15 +23.3pp (floor +3.9pp)
AVAX AVAX →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 18.0% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 287 15 —
DOT DOT →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 20.4% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 264 15 —
ENA ENA →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 16.1% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 334 15 —
HOOD HOOD →
Measurement note
HOOD levels hit 28% of the time, checked over 46 windows across 10 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 9.7%. That is 13.9 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor -4.5 points.
Serving 28.2% 9.8% 46 10 +13.9pp (floor -4.5pp)
HYPE HYPE →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 20.5% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 341 15 —
INJ INJ →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 9.9% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 331 15 —
LINK LINK →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 32.5% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 272 15 —
LTC LTC →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 27.4% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 244 15 —
MRVL MRVL →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 8.5% over 13 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 190 13 —
MSTR MSTR →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 12.2% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 170 15 —
NEAR NEAR →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 21.1% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 345 15 —
NVDA NVDA →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 16.5% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 272 15 —
ONDO ONDO →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 15.1% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 289 15 —
OP OP →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 17.6% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 271 15 —
POL POL →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 23.0% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 208 15 —
SEI SEI →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 18.0% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 196 15 —
SNDK SNDK →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 9.2% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 341 15 —
SOXL SOXL →
Measurement note
SOXL levels hit 9% of the time, checked over 347 windows across 15 independent days. The cautious number (95% floor): 2.1%. That is -4.8 points above the no-model mass-weighted baseline (14.2%), cautious floor -12.1 points.
Serving · floor watch 9.5% 2.1% 347 15 -4.8pp (floor -12.1pp)
SUI SUI →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 19.6% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 324 15 —
TAO TAO →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 17.7% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 292 15 —
TIA TIA →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 6.5% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 293 15 —
TRX TRX →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 56.8% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 217 15 —
TSLA TSLA →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 7.3% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 165 15 —
UNI UNI →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 18.6% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 316 15 —
WIF WIF →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 16.9% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 219 15 —
XLM XLM →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 23.6% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 289 15 —
ZEC ZEC →
Why it is withheld
Benched by the served-floor governance. The number that benched it is public: at-exclusion floor 12.2% over 15 independent days. Re-inclusion is earned, not assumed: floor ≥ 30.0% held over consecutive confirmed cycles plus sustained time. Live status: accruing.
Excluded · accruing — — 348 15 —

The independent unit is the UTC DAY, not the correlated intra-day window: the cautious bound is computed on held-out day clusters so the interval never reads tighter than the evidence supports. Edge = hit rate minus the governed pool's mass-weighted no-model baseline, with its own 95% floor; per-coin pages: /coins/<SYMBOL> · full governed JSON: /proof/stats.

Nothing swept aside

Additional records, including the experiments that have not proven edge.

These records matter, but they are not the Money Map’s headline claim. Open any section to inspect its current measured state, counts and cautious bounds.

Directional experiments Includes unvalidated and no-edge states

Directional calls: the honest state: accruing

A separate experiment tries to call DIRECTION (up / down / sideways), pre-registered so the rules cannot be tuned to the result. It publishes a number only after the pre-registered gate clears (enough resolved calls, enough days, and a cautious bound that beats guessing). Until then the state is UNVALIDATED and the counters are the disclosure: evidence in progress, never a signal.

UNVALIDATED · accruing Engine Read directional stream (rule registered 2026-07-26T17:20:00Z)
1 resolved calls so far (need 60)
1 days so far (need 14)
1 calls emitted, last 30d (of 40,330 evaluated)

Abstentions are disclosed, never graded; a realized sideways outcome counts as a miss. Descriptive history, not a forecast.

BETA · measured, edge not proven Shadow directional stream: the graduation track
11.7% hit rate on resolved shadow calls
11.0% 95% lower bound
7,545 resolved calls over 47 days
69.2% do-nothing base rate, same calls (floor 68.2%)

BETA: enough resolved evidence to publish the track record with its bound; the beat-the-base-rate gate has NOT cleared (no edge claim). The graduation gate that remains: the cautious bound of the hit rate (11.0%) must beat the cautious bound of doing nothing (68.2%): not yet cleared.

Watch the validation run live: next rung: VALIDATED
resolved calls
7545 / 120
resolved days
47 / 28

At 120 resolved calls and 28 days the stream is re-measured against its pre-registered bar: pass or fail, we publish the result. Zero is a real state: the counters ARE the disclosure.

A never-served side ledger; the ladder is pre-registered (UNVALIDATED → BETA needs 60 resolved calls over 14 days → VALIDATED needs 120 over 28 and a cautious bound that beats doing nothing: the realized sideways base rate over the same calls, never just beating zero). Verdict computed 2026-11-16T12:19:01Z by the accuracy loop; this page renders that exact block. Descriptive history, not a forecast.

The 3-class number: read this one carefully

Sideways-base-rate number, not directional edge Engine Read 3-class hit rate (1h horizon, trailing 7 days)

Our engine currently calls sideways 100.0% of the time, and the market actually moved sideways 61.5% of the time in this window. So the 61.5% below mostly measures how sideways the market was: it is a sideways-base-rate number, not directional skill. The honest check is the residual (our rate minus the base rate): +0.0pp here. Directional calls emitted in the window: 0. Directional accuracy is UNVALIDATED and we say so rather than dress this number up as proof of foresight.

61.5% 3-class hit rate (= the sideways base rate while all calls are sideways)
60.5% 95% lower bound
9,100 scored windows
+0.0pp residual over doing nothing

The per-regime residual check (does the engine beat always-saying-sideways in any volatility regime?) has not been computed yet. The accuracy loop writes it each round. We don’t estimate it.

Measured 2026-11-16T12:19:01Z · descriptive history, not a forecast.

Discipline and reference advisories Separate records, never blended into map accuracy

Discipline advisories: walk-forward record

Measured · descriptive Advisory correctness, trailing 30 days

The product's discipline advisories (e.g. “hold”) are scored after the fact: 67.4% proved correct, 95% lower bound 52.5%, over 43 independent advisory windows in the trailing 30 days. Independent means de-duplicated: the raw repeat count runs about 1.0× higher from re-emissions of the same open position, and we never count those as independent evidence. Descriptive history, not a forecast.

Reference-desk advisories: no open position needed

Hypothetical · measured Reference watchlist (BTC/ETH/SOL/XRP/DOGE/BNB/ADA/AVAX/LTC/NEAR/DOT/TRX/XLM/AAVE/POL), trailing 30 days

The same discipline engine also scores a fixed reference watchlist as hypothetical advice: reference-desk units with no open position behind them, graded by the identical 4-hour rule as the position advisories above. 45.8% proved correct, 95% lower bound 43.7%, over 2,189 graded reference windows in the trailing 30 days. This block is never blended into the position-advisory record: it has its own count and its own basis. Descriptive history, not a forecast.

45.8% reference advice proved correct
43.7% 95% lower bound
2,189 graded reference windows
30 trailing days

The full public track record of this stream: /reference-desk: hypothetical, no capital, measured.

Independent tape checks Venue match rate, coverage and seven-day checks

Is the underlying tape real? Independently re-checked

Every few minutes we re-verify our own liquidation tape against independent exchange references. Match rate = how often our tape agreed when a check was possible; coverage = how often a check was possible. Both shown with the check count; neither hides the other.

VenueMatch rate95% floorCoverageChecks (7d)
binance 100.0% 100.0% 99.9% 63,840
bybit 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 63,840
deribit 99.3% 99.2% 100.0% 29,925
deribit: measured since 2026-07-29 (REST capture era). Before that, the feed structurally couldn’t see liquidations (no data (capture blind 2023-10→2026-07)), and we say so.
kraken 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 63,840
okx 99.8% 99.8% 100.0% 63,840

From proof to product

See the measured levels on the Money Map.

Start with the delayed BTC map without an account. Move to real time only if the product earns it.

Data freshness: levels calibrated 2026-11-16T12:53:11Z · ledger built 2026-11-16T12:49:06Z · engine 3-class measured 2026-11-16T12:19:01Z · advisories scored 2026-11-16 13:20 UTC · X/Twitter news corpus PAUSED (API credits depleted since 2026-08-12 01:44 UTC): an honest gap, disclosed